NY Public Payroll Watch
  Home Daily Updates News Clips Links Contact Us  

Empire Center for New York State Policy
 
 
Taylor Made: The Cost and Consequences of New York's Public-Sector Labor Laws
by Terry O'Neil and E.J. McMahon

Defusing New York's Public Pension Bomb: A Fair Approach for Workers and Taxpayers
by E.J. McMahon

 
Two-Year Rise in State Payroll May Add $700 Million in Costs
October 2008

Workforce Turnover Offers Budget Savings Potential
February 2008

    ARCHIVE >>
 

To receive regular updates from NY Public Payroll Watch, type your email address in the box below and click "submit."

Email:
For Email Marketing you can trust
 
 

January 05, 2009

Niagara County's new family leave policy

Under a newly approved policy, Niagara County employees must use any accrued paid leave time (such as sick leave) simultaneously when they take advantage of a federal Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993.

Continue reading...


December 24, 2008

Happy Holidays!

NY Public Payroll Watch will resume blog posts on January 5. In the meanwhile, check our News Clips section, which will be regularly updated.




December 22, 2008

The costs of arbitration

Suffolk County police officers receive as many as 100 days off a year (not counting weekends), perks that County Executive Steven Levy calls "ridiculous" and blames on the state's binding arbitration law.

Continue reading...


December 18, 2008

Bloomberg on "gold-plated" pensions

New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg, writing in an op-ed, endorses Governor Paterson's pension reform proposal, saying his city cannot afford to "continue to offer the next generation of workers gold-plated pension benefits that even the most successful companies can't afford today".

Continue reading...


December 17, 2008

Tier V: Back to the Future

Governor David Paterson has proposed creating a Tier V pension system for newly hired employees, a tepid reform that basically mimics the state's early 1990's pension system--with one twist.

Continue reading...


December 16, 2008

Layoffs or givebacks?

Governor David Paterson, who will propose his budget later today, wants to wrest concessions from state employee unions to avoid the need for layoffs, according to a published report.

Continue reading...


December 15, 2008

Stealth PERB nominee

For the past two years, the Public Employment Relations Board has been unable to settle certain collective bargaining disputes, because of a vacancy on the three-member board. The state Senate may end the impasse this week by confirming Sheila S. Cole to the board.

Continue reading...


December 12, 2008

Tale of Two School Districts

The Buffalo Teachers Federation wants a judge to fine the city school district as much as $40 million for unilaterally switching to a single health insurance carrier. But if the union wins, will it cost some teachers their jobs?

Continue reading...


December 11, 2008

Katonah school administrators take pay freeze

Administrators in the Katonah-Lewisboro school district have agreed to forgo pay raises in the coming school year.

Continue reading...


December 10, 2008

Pension revolt

In what could be a wave of the future nationwide, Orange County, California, voters--by a whopping 75 percent majority--approved a ballot measure requiring that all future county pension increases be approved by them.

Continue reading...


December 09, 2008

Warrensburg seeks to re-open teachers' contract

In a rare move that may inspire cash-strapped school districts elsewhere in New York, the Warrensburg Central School District in the Adirondacks has asked its teachers union to renegotiate a contract which does not expire until 2011.

Continue reading...


December 08, 2008

Buffalo to post payroll on web

Amid data on property assessments and paying parking tickets, the City of Buffalo's web site will soon include the city's entire payroll.

Continue reading...


December 05, 2008

Teachers forgo raises--in Maryland

Teachers in Montgomery County, Md., have agreed to forgo their 5 percent raise to save Maryland's largest school district $89 million.

Continue reading...


December 04, 2008

Mayors seek to tweak pensions

The Conference of Mayors is calling for an overhaul in the state pension system, including creating a new pension "tier" for employees hired in the future. Unfortunately, while it would marginally curb rising expenses in the future, NYCOM's agenda is not particularly ambitious and does not represent fundamental change.

Continue reading...


December 03, 2008

Governor rejects retirement sweetener

Governor David Paterson has thrown cold water (at least for now) on state employees' dreams of a pre-Christmas retirement incentive.

Continue reading...


December 02, 2008

Not so fast, Joe

Former Senate Majority Leader Joe Bruno seems to think he pulled a fast one on taxpayers with his one big concession to "openness" in government.

Continue reading...


December 01, 2008

107 Massachusetts workers lose cars

Massachusetts Governor Deval Patrick is yanking car keys from 107 state workers, about 20 percent of those assigned government vehicles they can take home at night.

Continue reading...


November 26, 2008

295 Rochester managers get "incentive" bonuses

Rochester Mayor Robert Duffy has given performance bonuses--ranging from $2,001 to $5,000--to 295 city managers rather than across-the-board pay raises.

The Rochester Democrat & Chronicle, which filed a Freedom of Information Law request to acquire the information, reports that 356 non-unionized city workers were eligible for the one-time "incentive pay".

Continue reading...


November 25, 2008

Crunching the numbers

From Buffalo and New York City come reflections on the size of the state workforce. Buffalo News reporter/blogger James Heaney writes:

As I'm watching this train wreck of a state budget crumple like an accordion, I've wondered when any of our fearful leaders in Albany are going to start talking the obvious.

Layoffs.

Continue reading...


November 24, 2008

No cash for unused vacation

The Paterson administration's order to curtail a program allowing management-confidential employees to cash in five days of unused vacation has an employee organization threatening a lawsuit.

Before the Organization of Management-Confidential Employees files the legal papers, members might want to look at a measure signed into law by Governor Eliot Spitzer on January 28, 2008 (here).

Continue reading...


November 21, 2008

Allowing police to observe the Sabbath

Police officers in the town of Ramapo now can take off days without pay to observe their religions.

That means that an Orthodox Jewish rookie and a veteran officer who is a Seventh-day Adventist will not have to work Friday evenings or Saturday when they observe the Sabbath.

Continue reading...


November 20, 2008

Throwing sand in taxpayers' eyes

In Washington County, the board of supervisors is considering closing two popular beaches next summer to reduce the proposed budget. Meanwhile, they are about to vote on a tentative union contract that they refuse to make public until they ratify it.

Continue reading...


November 19, 2008

Buffalo, Chautauqua County keep public in the dark

The city of Buffalo and Chautauqua County are refusing to disclose terms of tentative collective bargaining agreements--that could raise local property taxes for years to come--until after the contracts are ratified.

Continue reading...


November 18, 2008

Census: NYS local government payroll exceeds national average

The federal government has released its 2007 survey of public sector employment in the states, showing New York localities exceed the national average in the number of government employees per capita.

Continue reading...


November 17, 2008

Westchester Medical Center salaries

As hospitals fight Governor David Paterson's proposed reductions, (here), the Journal News reports Michael Israel, the CEO of the quasi-public Westchester Medical Center is in line to earn as much as $1.2 million.

Continue reading...


November 14, 2008

Paterson's retirement incentive

Instead of the traditional pension sweetener, Governor David Paterson is effectively offering a different kind of incentive to many state workers eligible for retirement: Leave the payroll by December 31, or pay more for post-retirement health insurance if you retire later.

Continue reading...


November 13, 2008

Governor wants to freeze state worker salaries

Governor David Paterson says New York State cannot afford to give its employees a 3 percent raise in April. But will employee unions be willing to surrender what they won at the bargaining table?

Continue reading...


November 12, 2008

Mayors: Compulsory arbitration drives up taxes

The Conference of Mayors kicks off a new web site aimed at persuading Albany of "the dangers of shifting state taxes and costs onto local governments and property taxpayers."

Continue reading...


November 11, 2008

Imposing gag orders on union contracts

School boards and municipalities often keep the public in the dark about tentative contracts with employee unions until after they ratify the contracts, committing taxpayers to millions of dollars of spending over the life of the contracts.

Continue reading...


November 10, 2008

No more transit strikes, TWU promises

Roger Toussaint, president of Transport Workers Union, whose illegal pre-Christmas transit strike in 2005 nearly crippled New York City, has told a judge that his union will not stage a strike when its contract expires in January.

Continue reading...


November 07, 2008

Getting paid while doing union work

Taxpayers in Monroe County spent $1.6 million last year to pay municipal employees for work they performed on behalf of their labor unions, according to the Rochester Democrat & Chronicle.

Continue reading...


November 06, 2008

TWU elects senator sympathetic to Taylor Law changes

What changes may be in store now that Democrats have taken over the Senate? For a hint of the answer, consider the "Taylor Law reform" by Joseph Addabbo, who unseated longtime Republican-Conservative Senator Serphin Maltese of Queens.

Continue reading...


November 04, 2008

14 % two-year raise for CUNY chancellor

While the mayor is saying New York City agencies must do more with less, the City University board of trustees quietly gave Chancellor Matthew Goldstein a two-year raise of $55,000, which was first made public five weeks after the board approved it.

Continue reading...


NYC mayor hints about future layoffs

As he announced a tentative two-year union contract with annual 4 percent raises, New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg acknowledged the city may resort to employee layoffs in the future.

Continue reading...


November 03, 2008

Raises amid plans for possible layoffs

While New York City agencies are making plans for possible layoffs in the future, the city is locking down new contracts with its largest unions.

Continue reading...


October 31, 2008

And you thought New York was bad...

From today's Wall Street Journal story about the quickly-going-bankrupt city of Vallejo, California:

Continue reading...


October 30, 2008

Squeezing 180 days of school into 4-day weeks

High energy costs have ignited renewed interest in four-day workweeks. A somewhat skeptical, yet thoughtful, article--"The four-day school week: A fuel's paradise?"--reviews the limited research.

Continue reading...


October 29, 2008

State workforce grows under Spitzer-Paterson

Since October 2006 , the state payroll has increased by nearly 8,000 full-time equivalent employees, the Empire Center reports in a print edition of Public Payroll Watch.

Continue reading...


October 28, 2008

"Hard"hiring freeze turns slushy

Despite Governor David Paterson's July 30 "hard" hiring freeze, the state has hired 31,684 employees, the Buffalo News reports.

Continue reading...


October 27, 2008

Pension fund shrouds its losses

How much has the investment portfolio of the Common Retirement Fund plummeted in recent months? The state comptroller's office won't say, because it doesn't want to "create anxiety".

Continue reading...


October 24, 2008

TWU loses dues check-off appeal

The union that nearly crippled New York City in 2005 with an illegal transit strike got no mercy from an appellate court, which upheld a financial penalty imposed by state Supreme Court Justice Bruce Balter.

Continue reading...


October 23, 2008

Pension costs soar

New York State and its local governments are paying nearly 10 times more for public employee pensions than they did eight years ago, reports NY Fiscal Watch.

Continue reading...


October 22, 2008

Schools overfund employee benefit fund

Instead of reducing property taxes, school districts stockpiled an extra $407 million in a restricted employee benefit fund, according to the state comptroller.

Continue reading...


October 21, 2008

Shaking up the federal workforce

While all eyes are on the presidential election, a new report says the nation shouldn't lose sight of the 1.9 million civilian federal workers who will be critical to success of whomever occupies the White House.

Continue reading...


October 20, 2008

NYC teachers can't wear Obama buttons

A federal judge has ruled that New York City public school teachers cannot wear political campaign buttons at work, but he did allow them to hang political literature on union bulletin boards as long as they are not visible to students.

Continue reading...


October 17, 2008

A $39,000 retirement gift

Three months after West Genesse School Superintendent Rudolph C. Rubeis announced his retirement, the school board upped the longevity provision in his contract, allowing him to collect an extra $39,000 -- just 11 days before he retired.

Continue reading...


October 16, 2008

Keeping down health costs with employee buyouts

For employers, one way to reduce employee health insurance costs is to get someone else to pay for it--off loading costs to a business, government university or not-for-profit that employs the spouse of an employee.

Continue reading...


October 15, 2008

Should government workers wear campaign buttons on the job?

The American Federation of Teachers, which has endorsed Barack Obama filed a federal lawsuit Friday, seeking to overturn a ban on teachers wearing campaign buttons at public schools.

Continue reading...


October 14, 2008

Rhode Island: Retire now or pay later

In Rhode Island, state workers were given a choice: retire by September 30 or pay more health insurance benefits when you eventually retire.

Continue reading...


October 10, 2008

4-day weeks ended for Park police

Citing increased overtime costs, the state Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation is ending four-day weeks for 300 park police.

Continue reading...


October 09, 2008

Re-thinking government pension benefits

Plummeting tax revenues and increasing pension costs are sparking calls from Buffalo to Scarsdale to redesign public pensions for future employees.

Continue reading...


October 08, 2008

DAs urge veto of "double-dip" bill

A bill to address "revolving door" school superintendents--who retire and immediately are rehired by the same school districts--has the state District Attorneys Association urging a veto, because it also would apply to future retired police officers working at district attorney offices.

Continue reading...


October 07, 2008

Bill would crack down on pension fraud

Just days before Governor David Paterson is expected to sign a bill to stiffen penalties for pension fraud, Attorney General Andrew Cuomo announced three upstate attorneys have agreed to pay $347,000 to settle allegations against them.

Continue reading...


October 06, 2008

Unions get raises amid financial turmoil

Having agreed to 4 percent raises for New York City police and other unions, Mayor Michael Bloomberg has raised expectations of a generous pattern deal for unions still negotiating contracts--despite the Wall Street meltdown that's punching a big hole in the city's revenues.

Continue reading...


October 03, 2008

The budget squeeze Georgia-style

Local governments in Georgia, like those in New York, are struggling with red ink. Some are using a financial tool not available to New York municipalities; they are restructuring pension plans for new employees.

Continue reading...


October 02, 2008

"Late Start Wednesdays" accommodate teacher schedules

Hornell parents must change their work schedules once a month so Hornell teachers (protected by their union contract) don't have to change theirs.

Continue reading...


October 01, 2008

State agency moves toward "compressed" work week

With a goal of reducing energy consumption and employee commuting costs, the state Department of Environmental Conservation is considering allowing most of its employees the option of working "compressed" four-day weeks twice a month.

Continue reading...


September 30, 2008

Mixed messages for older police officers

Governor David Paterson has taken two approaches to the question of how long police officers should be allowed to work, approving a local option, but vetoing a statewide mandate.

Continue reading...


September 29, 2008

Tightening pension rules for local elected officials

Full- or part-time? That question may determine whether local elected officials have earned enough credits to qualify for a guaranteed public pension. While requiring more documentation, State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli's new pension eligibility rules still allow county legislatures, city councils, and town boards to come up with the final answer.

Continue reading...


September 26, 2008

Community college president up for $37,000 bonus

Despite a state budget freeze, despite rising property taxes, despite clamor over college costs, Onondaga Community College President Debbie Sydow may pocket a "performance" bonus as big as $37,000.

Continue reading...


September 25, 2008

NYC pays teachers without classrooms $74 million

With New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg ordering city agencies to cut $1.5 billion in spending, this might be the time to rethink a program that, this year alone, will pay $74 million to 1,400 teachers without permanent jobs.

Continue reading...


September 24, 2008

Utica teachers contract finally public

Now that the school board has ratified a proposed teachers contract, the Utica City Board of Education has decided it is okay for the people paying for it--Utica property taxpayers-- to see it.

Continue reading...


September 23, 2008

Raising police retirement age to 65

Two bills sitting on Governor David Paterson's desk would allow police officers and firefighters to reap huge pensions.

Continue reading...


September 22, 2008

What's the Utica school superintendent hiding?

Utica City School Superintendent Marilyn Skermont refuses to make public the terms of a proposed teacher contract--until after the school board ratifies it Tuesday.

Continue reading...


September 19, 2008

Spotlight on outside earnings of state lawmakers

Perhaps it was the federal indictment on Assemblyman Tony Seminario. Or a case of getting religion on the eve of Election Day. Whatever the cause, leaders of the state Legislature now say they favor requiring lawmakers to publicly disclose more about their outside income.

Continue reading...


September 18, 2008

Financial disclosure for government volunteers

Should financial disclosure be limited for unpaid members of government boards and advisory councils? Local governments as diverse as St. Lawrence County and New York City are grappling with that question.

Continue reading...


September 17, 2008

Feds nix four-day week for U.S. government employees

While local governments across New York are exploring the possibility of four-day weeks for their employees, the federal Office of Personnel Management (OPM) has rejected the idea.

Continue reading...


September 16, 2008

Judge rules California city bankrupt

Vallejo, California, is about to become an interesting case study in what happens to municipal union contracts when a city goes bust. Because Vallejo is now bankrupt. Not nearly bankrupt as New York City as in 1975, but officially bankrupt as declared by a federal judge.

Continue reading...


September 15, 2008

Opening union contract negotiations to the public

New York State bars the public from attending collective bargaining sessions between the Governor's Office of Employee Relations and unions representing state government employees--although the negotiations likely will commit taxpayers to hundreds of millions of dollars of spending.

Continue reading...


September 12, 2008

New Jersey charging rural towns for State Police patrols

Two neighboring states, New Jersey and Pennsylvania, are rethinking their long-time practice of providing free state police protection to communities without their own police forces.

New Jersey plans to charge 89 communities nearly $13 million for state police patrols, a service that has been free since 1921, reports Stateline.org, an online publication of the Pew Research Center.

Continue reading...


September 11, 2008

How much training does an arresting officer need?

Peace officers--with a few as 10 hours of police training--can make warrantless searches and arrests in New York. While the Legislature apparently has no problem with that, Governor David Paterson does.

Continue reading...


September 10, 2008

Pressuring public employees to sign nondisclosure pacts

While directing his staff to draft a bill banning public authorities from requiring employees to sign nondisclosure pacts, Governor David Paterson also might want to take a look at severance agreements negotiated by school districts and local governments.

Continue reading...


September 09, 2008

Paterson dumps Legislature's retiree health taskforce for his own

The Legislature will get what it says it wants--a taskforce to study health benefits for retired government workers. But the taskforce Governor David Paterson will name won't look like the one he vetoed Friday.

Continue reading...


September 08, 2008

Paterson allows harnessing of retiree health benefits

With his veto of a union-backed bill, Governor David Paterson has given local governments--and state government itself--the ability to contain growing costs of providing health benefits to their retired employees.

Continue reading...


September 05, 2008

Elusive Fort Edward teacher contracts

Although the Fort Edward school board approved a new labor agreement with its teachers union on June 24, the public has yet to see a copy of the contract.

Continue reading...


September 04, 2008

Here's $160,000. Now go away.

Residents of the East Greenbush Central School District in Rensselaer County may never know why Superintendent Dr. Rebecca Furlong was shown the door last December after four months on the job. However, they now can learn that her severance package was far richer than the district publicly revealed.

Continue reading...


September 03, 2008

Democracy TWU-style

Free speech apparently is not tolerated by leaders of the union that nearly crippled New York City with an illegal transit strike in 2005.

Continue reading...


September 02, 2008

Retiree health bill hits governor's desk

No labor bill generated more controversy this year than a measure on Governor David Paterson's desk that could lead to increased local property taxes for years to come.

Continue reading...


August 29, 2008

Teacher pay raises continue despite expired contracts

As schools open, teachers at 30 percent of New York school districts will be working under expired union contracts, but that doesn't mean teachers are going without pay raises.

Continue reading...


August 28, 2008

Granting peace officer status

When the Legislature sent him 16 bills designating various local officials as peace officers in 2007, Governor Eliot Spitzer vetoed every one. Now Governor David Paterson must decide the fate of 11 similar bills.

Continue reading...


August 27, 2008

Disciplining State Police investigators

With a bill awaiting his signature or veto, Governor David Paterson will decide who gets the final say when disciplining members of the Bureau of Criminal Investigation of the State Police: the superintendent of the State Police or an outside arbitrator.

Continue reading...


August 26, 2008

Working longer to earn lifetime health benefits

Nurses in the metropolitan New York area might find higher salaries at nonpublic hospitals, but they can't beat the post-retirement health benefits that Westchester County Medical Center offered until recently.

Continue reading...


August 25, 2008

Alabama warns its employees: trim your belly or your wallet

The state of Alabama hopes to motivate state employees to lose weight by charging obese employees $25 a month for health insurance that otherwise is free.

Continue reading...


August 22, 2008

Paterson administration defines "hard hiring freeze"

The Paterson administration put state agencies on notice that there will be few ways to get around its "hard hiring freeze," which also bans promotions, transfers and positions upgrades "unless individually justified."

Continue reading...


August 21, 2008

Gripes about prison grub dismissed by pension system

Inmates aren't alone in complaining about prison cuisine.

Peter Renda Sr., a retired New York City corrections officer, says 20 years of jail food--and job stress--led to his heart attack in 2006.

Continue reading...


August 20, 2008

A whale of an oversight

Sag Harbor is a picturesque old whaling village on the eastern end of Long Island. Its school district has only 870 students and 187 employees. When the district needed an interim administrator, it hired a familiar face, a retired principal of the high school.

Continue reading...


August 19, 2008

Employee or contractor: Will the IRS have the last word?

New York State's attorney general or comptroller may not have the last word on whether a school district attorney, accountant or physician is an outside contractor, who thus is not qualified for government pension benefits.

A little federal agency known as the Internal Revenue Service may have a different opinion.

Continue reading...


August 18, 2008

State Police negotiate 14%, four-year raise

Coming two days in advance of an "emergency" legislative session that he called to deal with a looming $6.4 budget shortfall, the timing of Governor David Paterson's tentative contract deal with the State Police Benevolent Association (PBA) is an eyebrow-raiser, to say the least.

Continue reading...


August 15, 2008

Top 100 state earners

Ninety-two of the 100 highest compensated state employees in 2007 worked for the State University of New York, according to an analysis by the Gannett News Service.

Continue reading...


August 14, 2008

Teachers union's financial muscle

New York State United Teachers sent $2.3 million to local teachers unions on the eve of school budget votes this spring, according to the New York Public Interest Research Group.

Continue reading...


August 13, 2008

Breaking news of your divorce...to your employer

Even after the ink is long dry on divorce papers, some government workers illegally continue to list former wives, husbands and stepchildren as dependents on their health insurance policies.

Continue reading...


August 12, 2008

Insuring ex-step kids?

With New Yorkers marrying, divorcing and remarrying, entering and exiting domestic partnerships, having kids and acquiring step kids who later become ex-step kids, it can't be an easy job to keep track of who legitimately qualifies to get state employee health benefits under family coverage plans.

Continue reading...


August 11, 2008

Transparency reports: teacher pensions, state overtime

In the latest effort to make public records accessible to the public, the Buffalo News posted annual pensions for retired teachers, using data from the New York State Teachers Retirement System.

Continue reading...


August 08, 2008

Paterson vetoes labor bills

Governor David Paterson has vetoed a series of potentially costly bills sought by public employee unions.

Continue reading...


August 07, 2008

Eyeing legislative staffs

With the state facing a $6.4 billion deficit next year, a Buffalo TV station asks, "Should cuts by state lawmakers start with their own staff?"

Continue reading...


August 06, 2008

Hey, we never knew that

Trolling through the SeeThroughNY.net website, a reporter for the Schenectady Daily Gazette discovered the chairman of the Schenectady County Republican Party has a part-time patronage job in the Assembly.

Continue reading...


August 05, 2008

Expanding binding arbitration

Legislative sponsors say a bill to extend binding arbitration will have no fiscal impact, but then why are downstate judicial employees so eager to have Governor Paterson sign the measure?

Likewise, why are unionized employees of the Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority pushing a similar bill?

Continue reading...


August 04, 2008

Relocating state employees

Governor David Paterson's ability to save money by restructuring the state workforce would be hindered by a union-backed bill that has hit his desk.

Continue reading...


August 01, 2008

Making public information public

The Empire Center's new SeeThroughNY.net transparency site bogged down under the impact of more than 40,000 unique "hits" in less than 24 hours after it was released at noon on Thursday--and many of the initial searches came from state workers, according to our web statistics.

Continue reading...


July 31, 2008

Watch this space

Today about noon, the Empire Center for New York State Policy will unveil a government transparency project. In a word, it's awesome.

Despite having access to insider information, NY Public Payroll Watch will respect the news embargo. All this secrecy about transparency is rather amusing

For the scoop, check the Empire Center's website (here) this afternoon. We'll also link to the site here.

Continue reading...


July 30, 2008

"We confront harsh times"

Whenever a New York governor talks about budget deficits--a too frequent occurrence during past 35 years--state workers get the jitters.

In a statewide speech Tuesday, Paterson said he is calling the Legislature to Albany to "an emergency economic session" on August 19.

Continue reading...


July 29, 2008

Loophole in attorney pension bill

Responding to news stories about private attorneys earning government pension credit for advising school districts, the Legislature approved such a narrow solution that it doesn't apply to Newsday's latest revelation: attorneys listed on fire district payrolls.

Continue reading...


July 28, 2008

Paterson signs cancer screening bill, but warns not again

After offering reasons to veto it, Governor David Paterson signed a bill giving public employees an extra half day of paid leave annually for breast or prostate cancer screening.

In doing so, however, he fired a warning: expect a veto next time.

Continue reading...


July 25, 2008

Expensive goodbyes

In the village of Port Chester and the Cambridge Central School District, taxpayers will be paying for severance packages for departing executives--as well as salaries of their replacements.

Continue reading...


July 24, 2008

Unions triumph

No more negotiating at the bargain table. No more lobbying the Legislature. Public employee unions won big time Thursday when Governor David Paterson signed into law a measure that means the unions will never worry about collecting millions of dollars of agency shop fees from nonunion members.

Continue reading...


July 23, 2008

Governor seeks advice

To sign or to veto? That is the question. In an unusual move, Governor David Paterson issued a press release soliciting additional advice on what action he should take today on a bill granting state and local government workers four hours of paid leave annually for breast and prostate cancer screening.

Continue reading...


July 22, 2008

Fighting fires

In 1736--a good forty years before he helped draft the Declaration of Independence--Benjamin Franklin was putting out fires in Philadelphia, where he founded an all-volunteer fire company. Today Americans are still debating the best way to fight fires.

Continue reading...


July 21, 2008

Collective bargaining in sunlight

When government officials in New York and public employee unions sit down to negotiate labor contracts, the public is shut out. That's not the case in seven states: Florida, Kansas, Minnesota, Montana, Oregon, Tennessee and Texas.

Continue reading...


July 18, 2008

Joe Bruno's golden stallion

Today as Joe Bruno rides into the sunset, to borrow his phrase, he can ride high in the saddle with an annual pension of approximately $95,000--only $8,000 less than his take-home pay (after state and FICA taxes) when he was the $120,500-a-year Senate majority leader.

Continue reading...


July 17, 2008

Recycling school superintendents

School districts must search aggressively for a new superintendent before they can hire a retired superintendent as a temporary replacement, under new Department of Education regulations.

Continue reading...


July 16, 2008

Transparency for unions

Labor unions would be required to disclose the benefits paid individual union officers and employees, under regulations being considered by the U.S. Department of Labor.

Continue reading...


July 15, 2008

Guaranteeing union dollars

Public employee unions are a step closer to realizing a long-time dream: a guarantee they will continue to receive millions of dollars annually from public employees who chose not to join labor unions.

Continue reading...


July 14, 2008

Happy Bastille Day!

NY Public Payroll Watch will resume July 15.




July 11, 2008

I quit (maybe)

Dear Boss:

Although I enjoy writing this blog, I fantasize about becoming a Nassau County employee. After only five years on the county payroll, I'd get health benefits for life. Can you match that?

Lise

Continue reading...


July 10, 2008

Paterson vetoes discipline bill

This site recently posed the question: "Will Governor David Paterson say "yes" to a union-giveaway that Governors Eliot Spitzer, George Pataki and Mario Cuomo vetoed eight times?"

Continue reading...


July 09, 2008

Dousing the flames

Scorched by criticism of their agreement giving firefighters a 41 percent raise over five years, village of Johnson City nevertheless has turned down an offer by the Broome County to help with further labor negotiations.

Continue reading...


July 08, 2008

Sparks fly over 41 % raise

Our nominee for the Most Generous Public Sector Contract in New York State for 2008--granted the year is only half over--goes to a financially struggling village in the Southern Tier.

Continue reading...


July 07, 2008

Shrinking the workforce (Round II)

More state agencies have outlined plans to reduce their workforces in response to Governor Paterson's order to reduce state operations spending by 3.35 percent.

Continue reading...


July 03, 2008

Happy Fourth of July!

Continue reading...


July 02, 2008

Golden apples for teachers

The economy is tanking. Consumer confidence is plunging. Property taxpayers are screaming. But you wouldn't know it from recent teachers' contracts in New York State.

Continue reading...


July 01, 2008

Holding jobs for injured workers

Knowing their old job is waiting for them can provide a psychological boost to employees recovering from workplace injuries, but how long should a government employer be required to keep their positions unfilled?

Continue reading...


June 30, 2008

Volunteer firefighter incentive

Volunteer firefighters would be able to purchase health insurance at a reduced cost, under a measure approved by the Legislature.

Continue reading...


June 27, 2008

Another test for Paterson

Will Governor David Paterson say "yes" to a union-giveaway that Governors Eliot Spitzer, George Pataki and Mario Cuomo vetoed eight times?

Continue reading...


June 26, 2008

Union jackpot

In an end-of-session sweetheart deal, the Legislature gave public employee unions a gift that keeps on giving. By making the agency shop fee permanent, lawmakers assure unions a steady flow of revenue for years to come.

Continue reading...


June 25, 2008

Vetoing health savings

Public employee unions could veto any attempt to alter retiree health benefits--even if a government employer found a way to offer the same benefits for less money, under a bill passed Tuesday by both houses of the Legislature.

Continue reading...


June 24, 2008

"Double dipping" takes a licking

A bill intended to crack down on "double dipping" by school districts attorneys and retired school superintendents sailed through both houses of the Legislature--only three days after it was introduced.

Continue reading...


June 23, 2008

End-of-session pension sweeteners

If history is any indication, you can't count on the Legislature to wrap up business time to adjourn today. However, you can expect it to pass pension sweeteners before leaving Albany.

Continue reading...


June 20, 2008

Waiting till 65 to give up the badge

The mandatory retirement age for local cops and firefighters would be raised to 65 from 62, allowing officers to collect pensions of up to 67 percent of their final average salary, under a bill that has passed both houses of the Legislature.

Continue reading...


June 19, 2008

Pick a number, any number

A bill allowing New York City government workers to retire early would cost:

a) $200 million.
b) Zip.
c) $68 million.

Continue reading...


June 18, 2008

Legislative countdown

As the legislators jam through hundreds of bills in preparation for Monday's exodus, even seasoned veterans concede it's tough to keep score on which bills remain alive and kicking.

Continue reading...


June 17, 2008

Overtime for legislative staff?

Legislative staffers would be eligible for overtime pay under a bill now in Assembly committee. The bill memo states:

Continue reading...


June 16, 2008

Protecting (some) convicted teachers

Measures aimed at keeping convicted felons out of New York classrooms are so narrowly drawn they would not automatically boot teachers convicted of bank robbery, arson or even murder.

Continue reading...


June 13, 2008

Making discipline negotiable

A court decision dealing with the disciplining of unionized cops and firefighters has prompted a legislative proposal that would have far wider implications for all public employees, including teachers.

Continue reading...


June 12, 2008

Diversionary Trojan Horse

The latest version the "Trojan Horse" bill--introduced Tuesday--is crafted to lock in the health benefits of only a select group of retirees: former police officers and firefighters.

The strategy appears to be that if you're having trouble sneaking a giant wooden horse undetected through the gates of Troy (or Legislature), try a smaller horse.

Continue reading...


June 11, 2008

Granting leave time to local union officials

Danny Donohue is listed on the state payroll as a motor vehicle operator, Kenneth Brynien as a psychologist and Larry Flanagan, Jr. as a corrections officer.

Continue reading...


June 10, 2008

Senate forecast for schools: partial sunshine

The Senate Republican Majority's plan to "rein in runaway spending" at school districts, announced in a news release Monday, would put a bright new spotlight on the salaries and benefits of school administrators--but only administrators.

Continue reading...


June 09, 2008

Retired, but not really

Despite a spate of recent news reports about "double dipping," (here, here and here) state lawmakers want to make it easier for government retirees to collect both pensions and paychecks.

Continue reading...


June 06, 2008

Shrinking the workforce (Round I)

With marching orders from Governor David Paterson to cut spending, all but one of the first 23 agencies submitting plans will reduce their workforce by attrition.

Continue reading...


June 05, 2008

Amending the Triborough Amendment

While its bold plan for a cap on school property taxes earned it headlines this week, the Suozzi Commission deserves to be recognized as the first gubernatorial commission to propose amending the Taylor Law since the Triborough Amendment was enacted in 1982.

Continue reading...


June 04, 2008

Speechless legislators move labor bills

Tuesday's New York Times featured a front-page story that cast a harsh light on the Legislature's history of approving pension bills based on cost estimates by actuary Jonathan Schwartz. Turns out those bills cost $500 million more than Schwartz estimated, the Times reported.

Continue reading...


June 03, 2008

"Trojan Horse" advances

Expensive health benefits for retired state and local government employees virtually will be locked in place by a bill on today's agenda of the Assembly Committee on Governmental Employees.

Continue reading...


June 02, 2008

"Body Part" Bills

Early detection of cancer saves lives. Having said that, let's consider pending bills to give government employees in New York additional leave time to be screened for breast, prostate, colon and cervical cancer.

Continue reading...


May 30, 2008

Who decides police discipline?

Can a police chief regulate drinking by his officers during the hours just before they go on duty--without first negotiating the rule with the police union?

Continue reading...


May 29, 2008

Pay raises without a contract

For public employees in New York, "working without a contract" does not mean foregoing annual pay raises. Under the Triborough amendment to the state Taylor Law, unionized workers continue to receive "step" increases in pay, as explained in more detail in the Empire Center's Taylor Made study.

Continue reading...


May 28, 2008

Counting pension credits for elected officials

When it comes to counting pension credits, the state retirement system allows local governments (i.e., elected officials themselves) to decide whether local elected officials should be considered full or part-time employees.

Continue reading...


May 27, 2008

$2,000-an-hour consultant

You might wonder how George M. Philip--who has a demanding job as interim president of the University at Albany--has time to serve as a $100,000 consultant to his former employer, the Teachers Retirement System.

Continue reading...


May 23, 2008

"Payroll padding" and "Double dipping"

Amid controversy over private attorneys collecting government pensions and the revolving door careers of school superintendents, state politicians and the education department are seeking solutions.

Saying "the system is broken and it has to change," Attorney General Andrew Coumo was joined by a couple of state legislators at a hearing Thursday in Riverhead focusing on ways outside attorneys and retired school superintendents game the state retirement system. As the Times Union reports, legisalators condemned the controversial pension practices:

Continue reading...


May 21, 2008

Double protection

If New York lawyers are convicted of a felony, they automatically are disbarred. But public school teachers convicted of a felony do not automatically lose their teaching credentials.

If private sector employees are injured, they collect workers' compensation and disability insurance, but are barred from suing their employers. Not true for employees of state and local governments.

Continue reading...


May 20, 2008

Protecting injured workers (and trial lawyers)

Trial lawyers, who got help from fellow trial lawyer Speaker Sheldon Silver last year, aim to kill a bill that could save state and local governments millions of dollars a year.
Continue reading...


May 19, 2008

Union bill drafting backfires

Bills promising pension sweeteners and early retirement incentives will not sail through the Legislature as quickly as unions hoped, thanks to the revelation that a union-paid actuary was admittedly minimizing the costs of these proposals.
Continue reading...


May 16, 2008

Unions draft "step above voodoo" bills

State law requires all bills increasing public pension benefits to include an estimate of their costs--the source of which must be identified in the legislation itself. For years, most fiscal estimates for pension bills affecting New York City have attributed to the same actuary, Jonathan Schwartz--who had a propensity for coming up with very small numbers.
Continue reading...


May 15, 2008

Unions see opportunity amid chaos

"Labor's in a good place," Richard C. Iannuzzi, president of New York State United Teachers, boasts in today's New York Times. He predicts the "somewhat chaotic and combative" situation in Albany will spell victory for union-backed measures. Continue reading...


May 14, 2008

Shining the spotlight

Over the past few months, the genie has squeezed out of the bottle thanks to old fashioned reporting about private attorneys collecting public pensions, double-dipping public employees and the state Legislature's penchant for pandering to unions at taxpayer expense.

Aggressive investigations by Attorney General Andrew Cuomo and Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli are keeping the stories alive. Continue reading...


May 13, 2008

Gilding the golden years

Count on the state Legislature to come up with new ways to enhance the golden years of retired government employees. As reported here yesterday, lawmakers are poised to pass a bill that likely will make it near impossible for the state and local governments to adopt cost-savings measures to control skyrocketing retiree health care costs. Continue reading...


May 12, 2008

"Pander alert"

When courting voters, legislators promise to eliminate unfunded mandates and reduce property tax. So how can they explain a bill that's greased for passage, one that would make it virtually impossible for the state and local governments to contain the soaring costs of health insurance for retired public employees?

Answer: The unions made them do it.
Continue reading...


May 09, 2008

Cuomo says "hundreds" may be involved in pension scam

Keeping track of government lawyers with questionable pension deals may soon require a computer spreadsheet. Attorney General Andrew Cuomo told the Times Union editorial board that the school district cases are "the tip of the iceberg." Continue reading...


May 08, 2008

Shhh. Don't tell anyone, but teachers question tenure

School principals complain it's almost impossible to get rid of bad teachers, who are triply protected by tenure, civil service rules and their unions. Apparently, teachers agree. Continue reading...


May 06, 2008

Overlooked

Overlooked in yesterday's round up of noteworthy stories was an account of a looming fiscal nightmare for state and local governments: paying for health insurance for retired public employees. Continue reading...


May 05, 2008

Stacking the decks at PERB and other costly tales

Perhaps the most underreported labor story is Governor Paterson's nomination of labor attorney Rosemary Queenan to serve on the Public Employment Relations Board, which settles collective bargaining disputes between public employee unions and the state and local governments. Continue reading...


May 02, 2008

Red ink for state, country club for state lawyer

Legislators, who spent only two days in Albany this week, were nowhere to be seen when state Budget Director Laura Anglin announced Thursday the grim news: the newly enacted $121.6 billion budget spends $5 billion more than the state expects in revenues. Continue reading...


May 01, 2008

A billion here, a billion there...

The true cost of savings from recommendations of the Commission on Local Government Efficiency and Competitiveness far exceed the $1 billion a year cited in news accounts.

Those are only savings the commission estimated for the 'minority of our recommendations'. As to its other recommendations, "the statewide magnitude cannot be recognized at this time." Continue reading...


April 30, 2008

Want a job?

While their tax revenues plunged, federal, state and local governments went on a hiring spree, adding 76,800 jobs in the first quarter of 2008. During the same period, 286,000 private sector jobs vanished, USA Today reports. Continue reading...


April 29, 2008

Settle or be sued, AG warns school lawyers

Attorney General Andrew Cuomo is dangling out-of-court settlements to a dozen lawyers he alleges wrongfully collected pension credits from school districts. Continue reading...


April 28, 2008

Facelifts aren't enough for Buffalo teachers

Despite the challenge of teaching in an urban school district, Buffalo teachers don't have to wear their stress on their faces. Their new health benefit package covers cosmetic surgery, courtesy of taxpayers. Continue reading...


April 25, 2008

Hiring while shrinking the workforce

Despite a soft hiring freeze, the Paterson administration is still filling jobs, AP reports. . Continue reading...


April 24, 2008

Paterson vetoes local government mandate

Lots to chew on today.

Before commenting on Governor David Paterson's first veto, let us note a potential sweetheart deal for the head of the Heath Insurance Plan of New York who could get $20 million worth of stock options if HIP becomes a for-profit company. (See News Clips.) Also there's more on the lawyer-pension scam and double-dipping Nassau County employee. Continue reading...


April 23, 2008

Find a job elsewhere, PBA tells members

When negotiating a contract, union bargaining teams often favor existing members with bigger pay raises at the expense of raising the ante for new hires.

In a twist on that practice, the union representing New York City police officers now uses the relatively low starting salary for recruits ($25,000 a year) in its campaign to win higher salaries for all cops. Continue reading...


April 22, 2008

Governor warns agencies to cut or be cut

Governor David Paterson warned state commissioners that if they can't come up with ways to cut their budgets by May 16, he will do it for them. Paterson wrote in an April 21 memo: Continue reading...


April 21, 2008

Golden handshake Senate-style

Exactly why Senate Majority Leader Joseph Bruno booted Jeffrey Lovell as secretary to the Senate Finance Committee is a mystery to all but a few Capitol insiders. Continue reading...


April 18, 2008

Lawyer Probe: Who pays FICA?

Among the annoying things about being self-employed is the high cost of hiring yourself.

For example, you must pay 15.3 percent for social security and Medicare taxes (FICA) on your income. In contrast, if you work for IBM or a school district, you'd pay 7.65 percent and your employer pays the other 7.65 percent. Continue reading...


April 17, 2008

No TV or "rubber rooms" for suspended Rochester teachers

The Rochester school superintendent has decided that if the city must pay suspended teachers, it should get some work out of them. Continue reading...


April 16, 2008

Car 54, where are you?

On a typical day, 141 Yonkers city-owned vehicles could be parked outside the homes of city employees and elected officials, who have permission to drive them home. The vehicles are supposed to be used strictly for city business, but are they? Continue reading...


April 15, 2008

Judicial robes with union labels

While they may rule supreme in their courtrooms, New York State judges have paltry clout at the Capitol where legislators have refused to increase their salaries since 1999. Continue reading...


April 14, 2008

To the winners go the spoils

If you work part-time for the Town of East Fishkill, you can't get health insurance--unless you get yourself elected to the town board. The East Fishkill politicians aren't alone in carving out special benefits for themselves, according to a Poughkeepsie Journal survey of municipalities in Dutchess and Ulster counties. In some cases, taxpayers continue to foot the bill for elected officials long after they've retired. Continue reading...


April 11, 2008

Exposing double-dipping lawyers

Attorney General Andrew Cuomo grabbed headlines when he announced his office is widening its probe of private-sector lawyers who collect government health benefits and pensions. It issued subpoenas Thursday to 90 lawyers and 180 school districts on Long Island and upstate. Continue reading...